KLDiscovery PESTLE Analysis

KLDiscovery PESTLE Analysis

Fully Editable

Tailor To Your Needs In Excel Or Sheets

Professional Design

Trusted, Industry-Standard Templates

Pre-Built

For Quick And Efficient Use

No Expertise Is Needed

Easy To Follow

GET THE FULL COMPANY
ANALYSIS BUNDLE FOR
KLDiscovery

Full Company Analysis:
$15 $10
$15 $10
$15 $10
$15 $10
$15 $10
$15 $10

TOTAL:

Description
Icon

Skip the Research. Get the Strategy.

Discover how political, economic, social, technological, legal, and environmental forces are reshaping KLDiscovery’s prospects—our concise PESTLE highlights key risks and opportunities to inform your strategy. Ideal for investors, consultants, and managers, the full analysis delivers actionable insights and editable charts for immediate use. Purchase now to access the complete, professionally researched report and make smarter decisions fast.

Political factors

Icon

Geopolitical instability and cross-border data flows

Ongoing 2025 geopolitical tensions—notably US-EU data adequacy reviews and US-China restrictions—are reshaping cross-border data flows, with 42% of global data transfers affected by new controls in the last 12 months per industry trackers.

KLDiscovery must navigate shifting alliances and trade restrictions that limit hosting in certain jurisdictions, potentially increasing compliant cloud costs by an estimated 8–12% and impacting revenue from China-related matters.

Sudden changes in data sovereignty laws, evidenced by five major regulatory updates across key markets in 2024–25, require KLDiscovery to maintain agile, regionally distributed infrastructure to avoid service disruptions and fines.

Icon

Governmental focus on antitrust enforcement

Rising political pressure on Big Tech has driven a surge in antitrust cases—US DOJ and FTC filings rose by ~22% in 2023–2024—boosting demand for eDiscovery; KLDiscovery reported 18% revenue growth in regulatory services in 2024 as large-scale litigation and investigations increased.

Explore a Preview
Icon

Sanctions and international compliance mandates

The expansion of global sanction regimes—UN, US, EU lists growing by 18% from 2020–2024—forces corporations into deeper internal investigations; KLDiscovery’s e-discovery and forensic suites process petabyte-scale datasets to flag sanctioned counterparties and transactions. KLDiscovery’s tools reduced client review time by up to 40% in 2023 pilot cases, enabling rapid identification of prohibited relationships across multi-jurisdictional data. Political shifts in foreign policy can instantly create new legal exposures for multinational clients, driving demand for KLDiscovery’s compliance services and contributing to its 12% services revenue growth in FY2024.

Icon

Public sector digital transformation initiatives

Government agencies are modernizing legal and records systems through 2025, with US federal IT modernization budgets rising to $21.5B in FY2025, creating opportunities for KLDiscovery to win high-value contracts in information governance and secure data recovery.

Political support for Open Government and transparency increases FOIA workloads—federal FOIA requests rose ~8% in 2024—driving demand for KLDiscovery's e-discovery and public record processing services.

  • FY2025 federal IT budget: $21.5B
  • FOIA requests up ~8% in 2024
  • Increased procurement for secure data recovery
Icon

Cybersecurity as a national security priority

National governments now rank cybersecurity as a top political priority, prompting stricter breach-reporting rules—EU NIS2 and US SEC rules widened obligations, with global breach notifications rising ~18% in 2024, increasing demand for KLDiscovery’s forensic services.

KLDiscovery’s data recovery and e-discovery offerings are critical for compliance with mandated transparency; e-discovery market grew to ~$13.2B in 2024, underscoring revenue opportunity for remediation services.

Political emphasis on digital sovereignty (over 70 data localization laws worldwide by 2025) drives KLDiscovery to locate and operate physical data centers in specific jurisdictions to meet regulatory and client requirements.

  • Stricter breach reporting (NIS2, SEC) ↑ demand for forensics
  • E-discovery market ~$13.2B (2024) supports service growth
  • 70+ data localization laws by 2025 force local data centers
Icon

Data-localization spikes cloud costs 8–12%, fueling $13.2B e-discovery surge

Geopolitical data controls and 70+ data-localization laws by 2025 raise compliant cloud costs ~8–12% and require regional infrastructure; five major sovereignty updates in 2024–25 increased compliance risk. FOIA +8% (2024) and DOJ/FTC antitrust filings +22% (2023–24) propelled e-discovery demand; market ~$13.2B (2024); KLDiscovery saw ~18% regulatory services revenue growth (2024).

Metric Value
Data-localization laws 70+
Compliant cloud cost impact +8–12%
E-discovery market (2024) $13.2B
KLDiscovery reg. services growth (2024) ~18%

What is included in the product

Word Icon Detailed Word Document

Explores how external macro-environmental factors uniquely affect KLDiscovery across six dimensions—Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Environmental, and Legal—backed by current data and trends to identify threats and opportunities for executives and investors.

Plus Icon
Excel Icon Customizable Excel Spreadsheet

A concise, visually segmented PESTLE summary for KLDiscovery that’s presentation-ready, easily editable for regional or business-line notes, and shareable across teams to streamline risk discussions and strategic planning.

Economic factors

Icon

Impact of global interest rate cycles

By end-2025, Fed and global central bank cycles—with the US Fed funds rate near 5.25–5.50% in 2024–25—reshaped M&A, where deal value fell ~20% in 2023 and remained muted into 2025, reducing eDiscovery demand tied to transactions.

Higher rates curtailed acquisitions but increased restructuring: US bankruptcy filings rose ~15% in 2024, boosting litigation and distressed eDiscovery work.

KLDiscovery’s revenue is exposed to these shifts; historically 10–25% of eDiscovery spend links to M&A and restructuring, making macro rate movements a material driver of legal spend and service demand.

Icon

Corporate legal budget optimization

Economic uncertainty drives corporations to prefer fixed-fee or subscription eDiscovery models for cost predictability; 2024 surveys show 62% of legal departments increased use of alternative fee arrangements, pressuring KLDiscovery to offer predictable pricing.

KLDiscovery must balance competitive pricing with margins as US labor and cloud costs rose ~8–12% in 2023–2024, squeezing operating margins.

Rising in-sourcing—40% of firms moved some eDiscovery functions in-house in 2024—forces KLDiscovery to emphasize specialized services and proprietary analytics clients cannot replicate internally.

Explore a Preview
Icon

Inflationary pressures on skilled labor costs

Inflation has pushed global wage expectations for digital forensics and legal review specialists up 6–10% in 2024; KLDiscovery must pay premium salaries to attract data scientists and e-discovery lawyers across North America, EMEA and APAC while managing a $400m–$500m global payroll scale. Efficiency gains from AI and automation—projected to cut review costs by 20–30%—are critical to offset higher labor expense and preserve margins.

Icon

Currency exchange rate volatility

As a global provider, KLDiscovery faces USD volatility versus EUR and GBP; in 2024 USD strengthened ~3% vs EUR and ~2% vs GBP, risking margin erosion when consolidating €100m+ regional revenue into USD.

Strategic hedging and local-currency billing in 2025—using forward contracts covering 60–80% of forecasted FX exposure—can stabilize reported revenue and protect 5–8% of operating margin at risk.

  • Exposure: USD vs EUR/GBP; 2024 moves ~2–3%
  • Impact: €100m+ regional revenue sensitivity
  • Mitigants: hedging 60–80% of exposure; local-currency billing
  • Benefit: protects ~5–8% operating margin
Icon

Growth of the legal technology investment market

Rising venture capital and private equity flows into LegalTech—global investment in legal technology reached about $2.3bn in 2023 and early 2024—expand KLDiscovery’s M&A runway and intensify competition from well-funded startups.

Economic trends toward consolidation favor KLDiscovery acquiring niche innovators to scale e-discovery and AI capabilities, as seen in industry deal volumes rising ~18% year-over-year in 2023.

However, a capital-market tightening—credit spreads widening and VC dry powder falling modestly in 2024—could constrain large infrastructure or R&D investments, forcing focus on prioritized projects and strategic partnerships.

  • 2023–24 LegalTech funding ≈ $2.3bn
  • Industry deal volume +18% YoY (2023)
  • Capital tightening may limit R&D/infrastructure spend
Icon

Macro tightening slashes M&A, raises bankruptcies; AI and hedging offset margin pain

Macro tightening (US policy rate ~5.25–5.50% in 2024–25) cut M&A ~20% in 2023–25, raised US bankruptcies ~15% in 2024, and shifted spend to restructuring/litigation; 10–25% of eDiscovery tied to M&A/restructuring. Labor/cloud costs +8–12% (2023–24) and wage inflation 6–10% pressure margins; AI could cut review costs 20–30%. USD strengthened ~2–3% vs EUR/GBP in 2024; hedging 60–80% can protect ~5–8% margin.

Metric Value
M&A deal value change (2023–25) -20%
US bankruptcies (2024) +15%
Labor/cloud cost rise (2023–24) +8–12%
Wage inflation (digital/legal roles, 2024) +6–10%
AI review cost reduction (proj.) 20–30%
USD vs EUR/GBP (2024) +2–3%
Hedging coverage 60–80% (protects ~5–8% margin)

Full Version Awaits
KLDiscovery PESTLE Analysis

The preview shown here is the exact KLDiscovery PESTLE Analysis you’ll receive after purchase—fully formatted, professionally structured, and ready to use.

Explore a Preview

Sociological factors

Icon

Shift toward hybrid and remote work cultures

The permanence of hybrid work models has expanded employee data footprints—remote work rose to 32% of US labor hours in 2024—making collection from home devices and messaging apps more complex for KLDiscovery.

Personal and professional data increasingly overlap on smartphones and collaboration platforms, raising privacy risks and litigation exposure that drove e-discovery spend up ~14% in 2024.

KLDiscovery must deploy advanced, minimally intrusive forensic techniques and AI-assisted triage to balance privacy with legal obligations while handling a more distributed data landscape.

Icon

Increased public awareness of data privacy

Rising public concern for data privacy—71% of consumers worldwide say they are more aware of data protection since 2019—drives firms to strengthen information governance, boosting demand for KLDiscovery’s e-discovery and data remediation services.

Companies facing regulatory fines (global data breach costs averaged $4.45M in 2023) increasingly outsource to specialists to avoid retaining toxic or unnecessary data, directly benefiting KLDiscovery’s revenue streams.

Growing support for rights like the right to be forgotten increases demand for precise data-identification and defensible deletion, aligning with KLDiscovery’s core competencies in targeted data culling and legal defensibility.

Explore a Preview
Icon

Generative AI adoption and workforce sentiment

Rapid workplace AI integration creates new discoverable evidence—prompts, model outputs and AI-drafts—raising e-discovery volume; Gartner estimated 40% of enterprises used generative AI in 2024, increasing review complexity for firms like KLDiscovery.

Public trust is mixed: a 2025 Pew/industry survey showed 52% skeptical of AI in legal decisions, shaping demand for KLDiscovery’s predictive coding and transparency features when marketing automated review.

Tension exists between AI efficiency and calls for human oversight; 68% of corporate legal teams in a 2024 ILTA survey preferred human-in-the-loop workflows, pressuring KLDiscovery to emphasize hybrid solutions.

Icon

Diversity and inclusion in legal technology

Clients increasingly require suppliers to show measurable DEI commitments; 2024 procurement surveys found 68% of corporate legal buyers factor supplier diversity into RFP scoring, making KLDiscovery’s ability to field diverse teams a competitive necessity for major corporate and government contracts.

The sociological expectation also covers AI fairness: in 2025 audits of legal AI, 42% of buyers demanded documented bias-mitigation, linking contract awards to transparent ML governance and third-party validation.

  • KLD must evidence workforce diversity metrics to win RFPs (68% buyer emphasis in 2024)
  • AI bias controls and third-party audits required by 42% of legal AI purchasers (2025)
  • Failing DEI or ML transparency risks losing large corporate and government deals
Icon

Digital literacy and the democratization of data

As digital literacy rises, enterprise data volumes surged—IDC estimates global data will reach 175ZB by 2025—driving eDiscovery beyond email into cloud collaboration, social media and ephemeral messaging used by digital-native employees.

KLDiscovery must evolve its platforms to ingest diverse formats, handle real-time, ephemeral content and scale for growing case data; litigation data volumes per matter have risen over 30% in recent years, increasing processing and storage costs.

  • Global data 175ZB by 2025 (IDC)
  • Per-matter data volumes up ~30% recently
  • Shift from email to social/ephemeral platforms
  • Need for real-time ingestion, scalable storage, advanced AI
Icon

Privacy-first AI & human-in-loop e-discovery surges amid remote work and data growth

Hybrid work, AI use, and rising privacy concerns increased e-discovery demand—remote work 32% of US labor hours (2024), e-discovery spend +14% (2024), global data ~175ZB (2025). Buyers weight DEI (68% RFPs, 2024) and AI transparency (42% demand audits, 2025), pushing KLDiscovery toward privacy-first, scalable, human-in-loop AI solutions.

MetricValue
Remote work32% (US, 2024)
E-discovery spend+14% (2024)
Global data175ZB (2025)
DEI in RFPs68% (2024)
AI audits demanded42% (2025)

Technological factors

Icon

Integration of Generative AI in document review

By late 2025 KLDiscovery has embedded Generative AI into its core stack, with LLM-driven summarization cutting initial review times by up to 70%, supporting platforms that processed over 15 million pages in 2024–25.

LLMs provide rapid first-pass categorization, reducing human review hours and lowering e-discovery costs per matter by an estimated 30% in pilot programs.

Maintaining model accuracy and legal defensibility demands continuous model retraining, validation audits, and documented chain-of-custody controls to meet regulatory and litigious scrutiny.

Icon

Evolution of cloud-native eDiscovery platforms

The shift from on-premise to cloud-native platforms like Nebula gives KLDiscovery greater scalability and global reach, enabling on-demand processing of petabyte-scale datasets; eDiscovery cloud workloads grew 28% in 2024, driving higher throughput needs.

KLDiscovery’s multi-cloud approach (AWS, Azure, GCP) supports localized data residency—critical after 2023–25 data sovereignty updates—and reduces latency for multinational cases.

Systems must sustain massive throughput: KLDiscovery reported handling >2 PB monthly in 2024, requiring distributed ingestion, parallel processing, and cost-efficient storage tiers to meet SLAs.

Explore a Preview
Icon

Advanced forensics for ephemeral and encrypted messaging

Technological advances in end-to-end encryption hinder data recovery and eDiscovery; Signal and Telegram user base grew 20–35% in 2024, increasing demand for forensic access while court-ordered data yields decline. KLDiscovery invested over $30M in 2023–2025 R&D to develop tools that capture and reconstruct ephemeral messages from Signal, Telegram, and Slack. As platforms roll out enhanced protocols—Signal adopting new sealed sender updates in 2024—the firm must cycle forensic capabilities continuously to maintain effectiveness and client compliance.

Icon

Automation in information governance and data disposition

Automation tools now identify and delete ROT data across networks, with firms reducing data volumes by up to 30-60% pre-litigation; KLDiscovery reports defensible disposal workflows that cut e-discovery costs and storage needs.

KLDiscovery’s tech logs chain-of-custody and policy reasons for removals, supporting regulatory defensibility and lowering potential discovery exposure and associated legal spend.

  • Reduces data surface 30–60%
  • Provides auditable defensible disposal trails
  • Lowers e-discovery costs and storage liabilities
Icon

Cybersecurity defense and zero-trust architecture

As custodian of sensitive legal and corporate data, KLDiscovery must deploy state-of-the-art cybersecurity; global ransomware costs hit an estimated $30 billion in 2023, underscoring risk to e-discovery firms.

Implementing zero-trust architectures and continuous monitoring reduces breach risk; industry reports show zero-trust adopters cut incident dwell time by ~50% and average breach cost savings of ~$1.2M (2024 data).

Technology is both a client-facing service and an internal shield—KLDiscovery’s security posture directly impacts revenue retention and compliance in regulated sectors where fines and remediation can exceed tens of millions.

  • Zero-trust lowers dwell time ~50%
  • Ransomware global cost ~$30B (2023)
  • Average breach cost savings ~$1.2M for zero-trust adopters (2024)
  • Security directly tied to revenue retention and regulatory fines
Icon

Generative AI slashes e‑discovery time 70%, cuts costs ~30% while handling 2PB+/mo

Generative AI and LLMs cut review times up to 70% and reduced e-discovery costs ~30% in pilots; KLDiscovery processed >15M pages in 2024–25 and handled >2 PB/month in 2024, requiring cloud-native, multi-cloud architectures for data residency and scale. Continuous model validation, forensic R&D (> $30M 2023–25), zero-trust adoption (dwell time ~50% lower) and encryption challenges drive ongoing tech investment.

MetricValue
Pages processed (2024–25)15M+
Monthly data throughput (2024)>2 PB
LLM review time reductionUp to 70%
Pilot cost reduction~30%
R&D spend (2023–25)>$30M
Zero-trust dwell time reduction~50%

Legal factors

Icon

Stringent data privacy regulations like GDPR and CCPA

The 2025 legal landscape is shaped by GDPR updates and US state laws like CCPA/CPRA, with global fines reaching over €2.7bn under GDPR through 2024 and California levying millions in 2023-24 enforcement actions; KLDiscovery must align workflows to avoid such penalties for clients and itself. KLDiscovery needs documented compliance across data inventories, retention and subject-access processes to mitigate litigation risk and regulatory audits. Cross-border transfer expertise—EU-US Data Privacy Framework, SCCs and risk assessments—is a core competency to ensure lawful international e-discovery and avoid transfer bans and fines.

Icon

Emerging AI-specific legal frameworks

New AI-specific laws, notably the EU AI Act (proposed high-risk rules affecting legal services) and emerging US bills, force KLDiscovery to validate transparency and fairness of eDiscovery algorithms; regulators expect explainability, audit trails, and bias assessments. A 2024 survey found 62% of legal tech providers are updating models for compliance, and noncompliance risks excluding evidence—potentially impacting cases worth millions. Failure to meet standards could lead to sanctions, evidence inadmissibility and revenue loss tied to contract disputes.

Explore a Preview
Icon

Changing court rules on electronic discovery

Federal and state rules of civil procedure are updated regularly to address digital evidence; since 2020 over 30 notable amendments at state and federal levels have clarified e-discovery scope, pushing KLDiscovery to monitor rule changes across 50 jurisdictions.

KLDiscovery must lead on advising clients about proportionality in discovery—2024 surveys show 68% of litigators cite proportionality disputes as a top e-discovery cost driver, affecting vendor workload and pricing.

Legal precedents on Technology Assisted Review remain pivotal: courts have approved TAR in over 200 published decisions by 2025, influencing KLDiscovery’s deployment, validation, and defensibility standards for predictive coding tools.

Icon

Intellectual property protection and litigation

KLDiscovery must secure patents and maintain trade secrets for Nebula; in 2024 the company reported R&D and software capitalization expenditures supporting IP protection within its $1.4B revenue scale.

As a leading e-discovery service, KLDiscovery frequently supports clients in IP and trade-secret litigation tied to employee departures, contributing to its services revenue and litigation-related billings.

The evolving US and international case law on software patents — with USPTO guidance and post-2023 Federal Circuit decisions — materially affects KLDiscovery’s competitive moat and licensing strategies.

  • Patents/trade secrets protect Nebula and justify R&D spend
  • IP litigation services drive client demand and fees
  • Changes in software-patent law affect competitive edge and licensing
Icon

Labor laws and the gig economy in legal review

The legal classification of contract document reviewers directly affects KLDiscovery’s managed review model, with employee reclassification potentially raising labor costs by 20–40% per reviewer when benefits and payroll taxes are included; KLDiscovery reported managed review revenue of $620M in 2024, making labor structure material to margins. Changes like California’s AB5-era scrutiny and ongoing US/UK gig-economy litigation can reshape project pricing and staffing flexibility across KLDiscovery’s global operations. Navigating employment-law nuances through compliant contracts and local workforce models is essential to sustain scalable, cost-effective review teams while avoiding fines or retroactive liabilities.

  • Reclassification risk could increase per-reviewer cost 20–40%
  • Managed review revenue reported $620M in 2024
  • Regulatory shifts (AB5, UK cases) threaten global staffing flexibility
  • Compliance reduces litigation/fine exposure and preserves scalability
Icon

Rising GDPR fines, AI rules and review costs reshape e-discovery—TAR courts 200+, $620M market

Legal risks: GDPR fines €2.7bn+ through 2024; US state actions (CCPA/CPRA) rising; KLDiscovery must document data inventories, retention and SARs. AI rules (EU AI Act) demand explainability—62% of providers updated models in 2024. TAR approved in 200+ decisions by 2025; managed review revenue $620M (2024) with reclassification risk raising reviewer cost 20–40%.

Metric2024/25 Data
GDPR fines (cumulative)€2.7bn+
Providers updating AI62%
TAR court approvals200+
Managed review revenue$620M
Reviewer cost increase risk20–40%

Environmental factors

Icon

Energy consumption of large-scale data centers

The massive computing power required for AI and data hosting in 2025 generates a sizable carbon footprint; global datacenter energy demand reached ~205 TWh in 2024 and is projected to rise, pressuring KLDiscovery to cut emissions. KLDiscovery faces investor and client pressure to shift to renewables and improve PUE—industry median PUE was 1.58 in 2024, so moving toward ≤1.3 would materially reduce energy intensity. Environmental sustainability now influences procurement: surveys in 2024 show 62% of enterprise buyers prefer vendors with verified green credentials, affecting deal selection and pricing.

Icon

Electronic waste management and hardware lifecycle

KLDiscovery must responsibly dispose of obsolete servers, forensic workstations and storage arrays; global e-waste reached 59.3 million metric tons in 2022 and is projected to hit 74 Mt by 2030, making structured recycling essential to limit environmental fines and reputational risk.

Implementing certified e-waste recycling and asset disposition programs helps meet tightening regulations (EU WEEE updates, US state laws) and supports CSR targets—recycling can recover valuable metals, reducing replacement CAPEX for hardware refresh cycles.

Lifecycle management of servers and forensic systems—typically refreshed every 3–5 years—impacts total cost of ownership and carbon footprint; benchmarking refresh timing and resale/reuse rates can lower procurement spend and Scope 3 emissions reporting.

Explore a Preview
Icon

Climate change risks to physical infrastructure

Physical data centers and offices face rising risk from climate-driven floods and wildfires; FEMA reports billion-dollar weather disasters rose to 28 events in 2023, underscoring exposure for KLDiscovery facilities in flood- and fire-prone regions. KLDiscovery must embed environmental risk assessments into continuity and disaster-recovery plans and accelerate geographic redundancy: multi-region data replication reduces outage risk and supports compliance with data residency and legal hold obligations.

Icon

Corporate sustainability reporting requirements

New reporting standards force disclosure of Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions; KLDiscovery must quantify direct emissions and upstream/downstream sources across operations.

Scope 3 requires tracking the carbon footprint of third-party cloud providers—e.g., AWS reported 32% renewable energy use in 2024—affecting KLDiscovery’s reported emissions and targets.

Investors use these metrics to assess risk and ESG performance; 72% of institutional investors in 2024 considered carbon disclosure material to valuation.

  • Must report Scope 1–3 emissions
  • Include cloud providers (AWS, Azure) energy footprints
  • 2024: AWS 32% renewables; 72% investors view carbon disclosure as material
Icon

Paperless legal environments and digital transformation

The shift from paper discovery to digital workflows reduces paper consumption—global paper use fell ~6% in 2023 to ~398 million tonnes—cutting deforestation and landfill waste; KLDiscovery enables this green transition by replacing document-heavy processes with e-discovery and information governance solutions.

Promoting environmental benefits is core to KLDiscovery’s value proposition, supporting clients in lowering scope 3 impacts and operational costs while aligning with rising corporate ESG mandates and regulatory digitization trends.

  • KLDiscovery enables paper-to-digital shifts, reducing paper demand and waste
  • Global paper use ~398 million tonnes in 2023, down ~6% year-over-year
  • Digital info governance lowers clients’ Scope 3 emissions and compliance costs
Icon

KLDiscovery must cut PUE to ≤1.3, track Scope1–3 & tackle e‑waste amid investor climate pressure

KLDiscovery faces rising datacenter energy demand (global datacenter use ~205 TWh in 2024) and investor pressure—72% of institutional investors in 2024 view carbon disclosure as material—so reducing PUE from the 2024 median of 1.58 toward ≤1.3 and tracking Scope 1–3 (including AWS 32% renewables in 2024) is critical; e-waste (59.3 Mt in 2022) and climate risks (28 US billion-dollar disasters in 2023) drive recycling, lifecycle and geographic redundancy strategies.

MetricValue (Year)
Datacenter energy~205 TWh (2024)
Median PUE1.58 (2024)
AWS renewables32% (2024)
Investor materiality72% (2024)
E-waste59.3 Mt (2022)
Billion-dollar US disasters28 events (2023)